Monday, July 16, 2012

Victim later turned into suspect




Two students of Yangchenphug Higher Secondary were arrested for battering a 24-year old man in Central Plaza in Thinphu on June 7.
The case was reported by one informer to the police when the informant found one man being stabbed at around 7pm while the crime occurred at around 6 pm.
The incident occurred when the victim who is a school dropout, went to the entire neighbor’s place looking for his wife and entered into a house where the two boys were residing and after he strangled one of the two boys, they took him out to the corridor and kicked him in every parts of his body; banged him on the pillars and wall of the buildings.
The boys in their statement stated that the victim was annoying them and was insisting them by saying that they would know about where his wife must have been.
 The boys after battered the man left him lying in the corridor and have gone to their home.
However he followed them to their place and met with the cook who is working with one of the restaurant in Central Plaza and he stopped him from finding the boys.
When he insisted to follow the boy, the cook lifted him up and dropped down on the cemented corridor and the cook left him.
Later when the cook was walking to his home, the man stabbed him from the back, which the police describe as a clean and regular major cut on the outer aspect of the right eye and on the right shoulder blade.
The police recovered the kitchen knife from the victim who later turned into a suspect.
The four suspects were arrested on the same day and they are under the police custody for necessary action.

Friday, July 13, 2012

The law is confused


A child is like a doll and is incapable of crime, so says, provisions in the books of law, but in the case of two minors who burnt down a hut, all loop holes based on this provision failed to save their legal guardians from the lawfully-ordered compensation payments.
The legal guardian of the two minors who set fire to a hut in Jungshina, Thimphu on February 17 appeared in Thimphu District Court for their final hearing on July 4.
The owner of the house who lost his home and his belongings for the fire will be compensated with Nu 18,000 while the tenant will receive Nu 9,000. The compensation will be paid by the parents of the two minor defendants within one month from the day of their final hearing.
Though circumstantial evidence of the crime committed by the two defendants is beyond reasonable doubt, the defendants are not liable to pay compensation in accordance to the principle of Doli Incapax which explains that a child is like a doll and is not capable of punishment to any offences committed.
Section 9 of Penal Code (Amendment) Act 2011 states that “if the defendant is a child of 12 years and below, he/she shall not be held liable for any offence committed by him/her.”
Section 9 of the same law book, ‘the Penal Code (Amendment) Act 2011’ states that a child can never be found guilty even if he/she has committed a heinous crime and the law does not allow them to appear in the court.
And yet, at the same time, there are provisions by which compensation becomes mandatory.
This confusion bears argument mainly because, of section 12 of Penal Code (Amendment) Act 2011 and section 111 of The Child Care and Protection Act 2011  which contradicts the principle of Doli Incapax.
The two sections state that “if a child is found guilty of an offence for which damages are appropriate, the court may order the parents or legal guardian of the child in conflict with law to pay the damages”.
The law is not clear whether the section 12 is applicable to section 9 or if it is only applicable to section 10 which states “if the defendant is a child above 12 years, the court shall sentence the child in conflict with the law to a minimum of half of the sentence prescribed for the offence”.
If compensated, the child is convicted and if not the victims are victimized wherein the court has to interpret the applicability and meaning of section 9, 10 and 12 of Penal Code (Amendment) Act 2011 and section 111 of The Child Care and Protection Act 2011.
In  the current case, the court ordered the parents to compensate the victims on reasonable and appropriate damages  caused,  since the mother of the two defendants agreed to compensate and also the country do not have separate fund called the ‘Solatium Fund’ like other countries to compensate in such cases.
The defendants are given 10 days to appeal to the High Court if they are not content with the final judgment of the District court but the victims are forced to be content when the law does not allow them.
In cases, where a child is in conflict with the law, the case should not be forwarded to the court according to the law, but in this case a victim pressurized the Royal Bhutan Police to forward the case to the court (in hope for compensation).
This is the first case of a child defendant forwarded to the court.

Friday, July 6, 2012

Standard guidelines for timber marketing


The community forest management groups (CFMGs) in the country are generating substantial income through timber sales from their Community Forests (CFs). The absence of proper guidelines for timber-marketing however proves a deterrent for many to venture into the same field.
The CFMGs can now look forward to better-streamlined timber marketing with Social Forestry Division (SFD) under Department of Forests and Park Services (DoFPS) in the process to develop or formulate timber marketing guidelines for the CFs.
CFMGs across the country are highly hesitant and skeptical of timber business in the absence of a definite marketing guideline for the timber commerce.
“The guideline will facilitate and guide the timber sales from CF,” said Karma Jigme Temphel of social forestry division. He said the development of specific guidelines will be done after comprehensive stakeholders meetings and workshops which will include the CFMG members.
The SFD official said that currently such timber marketing is reflected nowhere in the policies and rules.
The guideline currently is at the conceptual development stage and before implementation it will go through field tests.
The country currently faces an acute shortage of timber a gaping difference of 1.84mn cft between supply and demand.
A prominent reason for the shortage lay in the fact that majority of the community forests in Bhutan have harvested, way below the Annual Harvesting Limits (AHL). This is further substantiated in studies conducted in the past which mentions, community forest management groups harvest timber conservatively and at levels below the prescriptions in the CF management plan. The studies stated that the community forest management groups are very careful while they harvest forest products from the CFs.
All things considered, there is a need to standardize and encourage more CFs into timber sale which the studies mentioned as long overdue. This will have far reaching impacts not only in closing the timber-shortage gap but also on the poverty reduction which is predominantly a rural phenomenon.
A CF seminar on poverty held at Bumthang specified there is no such thing as standard timber marketing procedures at the national level and the procedure adopted by most of the CFs when it comes to timber marketing is based on trial and error.
It is deemed most vital the timber marketing guidelines be formulated so that the CFs are encouraged to indulge in timber marketing.

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Tsirang hails first as independent CF manager


Tsirang hails first as independent CF manager


In sync with the government’s vision to have Community Forests managed independently in all aspects by members without government support, three Community Forests (CF) in Tsirang recently made the successful transition to manage and plan all on their own with minimal government support.
Community Forests Management group members of Dangraybu CF under Doonglagang Gewog, Chirphen CF under Mendrelgang gewog, Darjeling CF under Rangthangling gewog in Tsirang Dzongkhag not only personally contributed money for the CF activities but also took the lead to execute the activities.
The members contributed certain amounts to meet the expenditures incurred in management planning and ownership certificate handing-over which conventionally is sponsored by the government.
The section head of Social Forestry and Extension Division (SFED), KJ Temphel said this is the vision of the government in the long run.
“This is the ultimate way forward for CF programs in the Country,” he said.  “Through enabling plans and policies, the government is trying to encourage such model of CF management in the country.”
An official of the SFED said a time will come when the CF members have to pay the foresters for provision of technical backstopping and other services related to CF. This means that the CF programs in the country should slowly mature and function independently. The government currently provides most of the supports since the program is in its infant stage.
Tsirang Dzongkhag Forest Officer, Pema Tshewang said he was overwhelmed and encouraged when the CF members came forward with such the proposal. “We know this has to happen one day and someone should initiate and take the step forward,” he said.
On the flipside many CF Management groups in the country are still largely dependent on government support.
Community Forestry Programs in Bhutan is about handing over a chunk of Government Reserved Forests with sustainable management, utilization and ownership rights to a group of communities. The program aims to enable these beneficiaries to generate income through sale of excess timbers and other income sources and help reduce poverty which predominantly is a rural phenomenon.
The program is incepted with the belief that the forests and natural resources within the proximity of the community are best managed by themselves and benefits should also flow to the communities themselves. “When the communities are entrusted with the responsibilities and the power to protect, utilize and manage certain portion of forests, the overall health of the forests improves,” said an SFED official.   
SFED is putting up concerted efforts toward creation of enabling environments for CF establishment. They have developed a CF strategy in Bhutan which is being implemented, while the CF Action Plan is under finalization. The training of 45 foresters on CF management planning, sponsoring of study tour to 22 CFMG members to Nepal, provision of training package on record and book keeping, seminar on CF for poverty reduction, economic analysis and market chain of timber products within CFs have been carried out.
Already major positive impacts have been witnessed since the program started. For instance, there has been drastic reduction of illegal activities while the number of forest fire incidences has also dwindled significantly. Officials claim that such programs have also helped bring degraded land under plantation.
Tsirang Dzongkhag currently has 24 approved CFs with 10 more in the offing. While at the national level, at the end of March this year, there are 382 numbers of CFs which comprise 17,000 households (CFMG members) which is almost 34 percent of rural households.  These totals to one-sixth of all rural households while 43,000 hectares or 1.5%of the overall forests areas in Bhutan have been handed over as CF.
Government targets to establish minimum of 400 CFs and hand-over at least 4% of government reserved forest land as CFs by the end of 10th five year plan.

Saturday, June 30, 2012


Man batters woman in an attempt to rape, Man sentenced to four years

The Thimphu District court sentenced a man from Samtse to four years of imprisonment for aggravated battery and  criminal attempt to rape a 24 year-old married women.
On April 20 at around 10 pm the convict 26 year-old Passang Dorji Tamang eve-teased the victim and later attempted to rape her. He slapped her, pulled her hair, kicked and broke two teeth, the right upper lateral incisor and lower lateral incisor.
The convict molested the victim, touching her breast and private parts. The victim managed to escape when she bit the convict’s hand.
The case was reported to the police at night and the victim was taken to the hospital for medical examination which ruled that the convict attempted sexual penetration and had bruised her breasts and private parts.
The assailant was arrested after a week later and admitted to the crime.
In the course of the hearing, it has been established that the victim is a married woman and to meet the end of justice, the charge has been amended in accordance with section 187.3of the Civil and Criminal Procedure Code of Bhutan (CCPCB).
The convict appeared for the final hearing on June 28 in the Thimphu District Court.
The defendant Passang Dorji Tamang is also directed to pay Nu 50,000 as per section 38 and 42 as a compensation and ancillary and incidental expenses incurred on the account of the offence committed by the defendant.
The court further directed if the defendant defaults on the payment of compensation, the defendant shall be in contempt of court and may be imprisoned until the fine is either paid or recovered as per section 43 of the penal code.
The court after consideration of mitigating and aggravating factors, ordered the sentence of two years for criminal attempt to rape a married woman and two years for aggravated battery to run consecutively since the defendant posed grave risk to the victim’s life when he battered the victim and attempted to rape her.
The parties to the case can file an appeal within 10 days of passing the judgment.
The victim is still undergoing medical treatment.

Friday, June 22, 2012


Porous borders: a boon for goons, bane for the law

To contain illegal trades in the northern and southern ends of the country is a most challenging task for Bhutanese law enforcement authorities. As a result, illegal trading of medicinal plants is up and on the rise.
Trans-boundary illegal collection of medicinal plants is rampant in Bhutan although enforcement officials are stationed at many strategic points. Illegal exploitation of resources by people from across the border according to the officials may compromise sustainability of Bhutan’s medicinal plants.
Such illegal collections are also often untraceable due to which authorities don’t have any concrete data on the quantity of the illegal exports.
Lyonpo (Dr.) Pema Gyamtsho said that Bhutan has always faced difficulties in legality, sustainability and traceability of medical plants in the country. “Due to porous borders both in north and south, much of it is traded not in very legal manner.” This Lyonpo said was because of the lucrative market it has in the international market.
In the north, it is mostly the Ophiocordyceps (Chinese caterpillar) which are being smuggled through the unguarded and unmanned part of the border while similarly in the south, Pipla, Star Anis (Illicium) and Fritillaria delavayi are few among many that are illegally ferried across the border.
This is also evident from the recent report of Revenue and Custom official seizing sacks of semi-dried Pipla from a driver of Indian origin.
Collectors from within the country also exert pressure on the resources sustainability.  “Poor collection is also happening rampantly,” said Lyonpo  (Dr.) Pema Gyamtsho. “The method of collection is very destructive that in many cases there is no regard for the revival and regeneration of the medicinal plant species.” This is happening both at the alpine areas in the north as well as sub-tropical zone in the south.
For instance, experts shared at the CITES regional workshop last Thursday, that it takes approximately, 5000 pieces of Ophiocordyceps sinensis (Chinese caterpillar) to make one kilogram. So, chances of getting over exploited if not managed properly cannot be overruled.
In particular to Chinese caterpillar, many mechanisms are in place to check over-exploitation both natural and man-made. The harsh and ruthless climatic condition in Cordyceps growing areas is a kind of a favorable condition for sustenance of the worms. Such inclement weather limits quantity of the worms collected. “The ‘bub’ grows within the thickets of the alpine bushes and it really takes experience to locate one. Hunting for 12 hours, many can gather only few pieces,” said an official.
Although officials said that it is difficult to put legal limitations, mechanisms such as restriction of collection time for only one month (From 15 May to 15 June) are imposed. During this period, enforcement officials sternly monitor the collection methods. The numbers of collectors are also kept at minimum through provision of limited collection permits from the forest and park services department.
Bhutan is home to more than 300 species of medicinal plants.

Wild driving claims numerous wild (lives)
Tanden Zangmo
A female adult Leopard cat (Felis Bengalensis) was killed on the spot when a speeding motorist crushed her on the expressway opposite to Samazingkha in Thimphu on June 21.  
The dead felid with major injury on its head and the jaws crushed was first spotted by Thimphu divisional forestry staff lying on the expressway when he went jogging early in the morning. He then immediately informed Forest Protection and Surveillance Unit (FPSU) of Department of Forests and Park Services (DoFPS). “When I reached the spot at 6 AM, the cat was already dead,” said Phub Tshering of FPSU.
Based on the wheel tracks of some big vehicle in the accident spot, officials believe that the animal might have been killed by a truck. With the leopard cat just about the size of a domestic cat, officials say that the trucker might have mistaken it for a common household cat. “Bhutanese have this superstition that a cat crossing your way will bring bad omen to commuter,” WCD’s Chief Forestry Officer, Sonam Wangchuk said together with Phub Tshering of FPSU. They believe that in order to avoid the cat crossing the way, the trucker might have killed it.
Forest Officials also added that if not for such intentional killing, it might have been carelessness on the part of man behind the wheel. “With better and wider asphalted road, speeding vehicles often run over the wildlife. This is the major threat in developed countries.” WCD CFO said. He agreed that it is increasingly becoming a trend in Bhutan too.      
It is likely that the cat got killed at night since it is a nocturnal wild animal was probably looking for a comfort zone. “The asphalt road remains much warmer when the temperature in the forests drops. So, the cat was perhaps lying on the warm tarred road.” Otherwise, they say the cat was looking for its prey which consists of small mammals, birds and poultry.     

As per the field guide to the mammals of Bhutan the leopard cat is described as having similarity with the household cat except that it has longer legs. It has spots and marks on the body similar to that of leopards and look like a miniature leopard but it had no rosettes on its coat and instead has soild black spots or patched.

The guide further describes that the cat is nocturnal but occasionally hunts during the daytime. The cat is found to be a solitary except during the mating season.

The normal size of the cat ranges from 35-60 cms while its tail measures 15-30 cms. The normal cat would weigh 3-7 kgs.

Like the common leopard, the leopard cat is one of the most adaptable cats. It occurs in the broad spectrum of habitats from tropical rain forest to temperate broadleaf and coniferous forest as well as shrubs and grasslands. They take shelter in hollows of trees.

The cat shows little aversion to presence of human and often lives close to human settlements. In Bhutan, the cat is found ranging from south till about 3,200 meters above sea level.

As per the guide book, the conservation threats of the cat globally are habitat fragmentation, poaching for its pelt and retaliatory killing by farmers. But in Bhutan, it does not face any major threat and enjoys a relatively undisturbed habitat.

The IUCN status as per the guide is lower risk.        

Meanwhile, a civet (Civettictis Civetta), rare species was also run over by the speeding vehicle on the national highway at Lumitsawa under Punakha dzongkhag on June 11.

According to Kezang Dawa, park Manager of Royal Botanical Park (RBP) Lamperi , this mammal is a nocturnal animal who prey on domestic hens and would have run over by the vehicle while it was wandering into the nearest village in search of food.
“This is a rare species and I have never encountered such animal before.” He said.
The Civet is a purely nocturnal generally solitary animal. Purely terrestrial it is poor at climbing and at digging, and it lives in vacant burrows left by other species. 
Civets are found in a wide range of habitats, but densely wooded areas and forests are preferred.  Civets are almost always found near a good source of water.
According to Park Manager, the civet was also run over on its jaw and which consequently has died after stern injury on its mouth.
Further, CFO of WCD also shared his experience from the Thrumshingla National Park in Bumthang. The east-west highway running through the heart of the park has claimed lives of wild animals in the past too. He reminisce incidences where small mammals and reptiles like Langurs and Snakes have succumbed to the reckless driving.  
The department officials are doing all they could to bring down such cases of wildlife being killed by vehicles. The precautionary messages imparted in the environmental education program are directed to creating public awareness on avoiding suck kills.
On the legislation front, the Forest and Nature Conservation Rules, 2006 is silent on such traffic part. While the affected can either kill or drive away wild animals causing crop depredation, it is restricted to only those not included in the Schedule I. Those listed in the Schedule I, which usually are those wild animals critically endangered and vulnerable to extinction are not permitted to kill at no cost. 
The dead specimen of both the dead wild animals have been surrendered to the Wildlife Conservation Division (WCD) Thimphu who further handed over to Taxidermy centre at Taba where it will be mounted. The mounted specimen will be used for the educational purpose especially to those visiting the centre. 
“This is a big loss from the conservation point of view,” said Sonam Wangchuk. He urges all the people especially those behind the wheel to be little cautious and spare the lives of innocent wildlife.